Home › The Reading Lab

Reads the words but does not understand

What helps reading comprehension in the early grades

The short answer

My child can read the words but does not understand. What helps?

A U.S. expert panel wrote that teaching a child to sound out words is needed but will not by itself bring every child to good understanding. Its strongest recommendation is to teach comprehension strategies, such as retelling the main points of what was read.

What the research found

  • 3 × Strong evidence
  • 1 × Moderate evidence
  • 1 × Minimal evidence
  • 3 × Expert advice, not a trial
  1. The panel wrote that teaching a child to sound out words is needed but will not by itself bring every child to good understanding.

    In the source’s own words“the panel believes decoding instruction alone will not produce desired levels of reading comprehension for all students.”
    Expert advice, not a trialSource 1, Introduction, p. 6
  2. The guide's first recommendation, rated strong, is to teach children comprehension strategies, which it says help readers understand more and get past difficulties.

    In the source’s own words“Comprehension strategies help readers enhance their understanding, overcome difficulties in comprehending text, and compensate for weak or imperfect knowledge related to the text.”
  3. The guide says strategies can be taught one at a time or several together, and both ways can help.

    In the source’s own words“The strategies may be taught one by one or in combination. Both approaches can improve reading comprehension, so the panel recommends that teachers choose the approach they are most comfortable with in the classroom.”
  4. One of the strategies in the guide is retelling: the child says or writes the main points of what was read.

    In the source’s own words“Students briefly describe, orally or in writing, the main points of what they read.”
  5. The guide's second recommendation, rated moderate, is to teach children how texts are organized, such as the parts of a story.

    In the source’s own words“Teach students to identify and use the text’s organizational structure to comprehend, learn, and remember content.”
  6. The guide recommends guided discussion about what a text means, and rates the evidence for it as minimal.

    In the source’s own words“Guide students through focused, high-quality discussion on the meaning of text Level of evidence: Minimal Evidence”
  7. The guide says time spent only on word-level skills will not be enough to make young children effective readers.

    In the source’s own words“Devoting time only to word-level skills will not be sufficient to help primary grade students become effective readers.”
  8. In the panel's experience, a text can be easy to sound out and still too hard to understand.

    In the source’s own words“In the panel’s experience, a text that is easy to decode may be too difficult for students to comprehend because the information might be complicated”
    Expert advice, not a trialSource 1, Recommendation 4, p. 32

What this means at home

  • After reading, ask your child to tell you the main points in their own words.
  • Talk about how a story is put together: who, where, what happened, how it ended.
  • Remember that a text can be easy to sound out and still hard to understand.
  • The free understanding check points to where understanding breaks down.

What the research does not tell us

  • For discussion about text, the guide says most studies either could not show cause and effect or were done with older students.
  • For predicting and using what the child already knows, the guide says only one study tested that strategy alone against no strategy teaching.
  • The guide is about classroom teaching of comprehension in kindergarten through 3rd grade and rests on the evidence as its authors judged it.

Sources

We read each of these ourselves on October 9, 2026. Follow the links to read them too.

  1. Improving Reading Comprehension in Kindergarten Through 3rd Grade. Shanahan, T., Callison, K., Carriere, C., Duke, N. K., Pearson, P. D., Schatschneider, C., & Torgesen, J.; Institute of Education Sciences, What Works Clearinghouse (NCEE 2010-4038). 2010.A U.S. government practice guide in which an expert panel made five recommendations for teaching reading comprehension and rated the evidence behind each.ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc/PracticeGuide/14

How we write these pages

  1. We read the source itself, not a news story about it.
  2. Every finding on a page names its source and where in the source it is found, so you can check it.
  3. We say how strong the evidence is, in the words of the people who reviewed it.
  4. We say what the research does not tell us. Most studies are done in schools, and no study can say what one child needs.
  5. If we get something wrong, tell us at hello@sounditoutreading.com and we will correct the page.

More from The Reading Lab

See all the research pages

More than worksheets

Does this sound like your child?

“Reads the words but cannot tell me what it said”

Read It, See It is a full 10-day plan, with a short video that shows you every step. The goal: on day 10 your child reads a short story they have never seen, tells you what happened, and draws it. It is the goal, not a promise.

  • 21 printable pages, one short day at a time
  • 11 short videos that show you each day before you do it
  • 4 sound tracks your child works with alone, while you step away
  • A check on day 1 and day 10, and a report
  • About five minutes a day from you
  • $19, one payment. 30-day money back.

See the 10-day plan →Or do the free 3-minute check first