Home › The Reading Lab

Handwriting practice

How to teach letter formation, according to an expert panel

The short answer

Does handwriting practice help, and how should letters be taught?

A U.S. expert panel on writing recommends showing a child a comfortable pencil hold and the most efficient way to form each letter, with short practice and letters written from memory as well as traced. The results it reports are for writing. It does not report an effect on reading.

What the research found

  • 7 × Moderate evidence
  • 1 × Expert advice, not a trial
  1. The writing guide says that when basic skills like handwriting take little effort, a child can give more attention to ideas.

    In the source’s own words“When basic writing skills become relatively effortless for students, they can focus less on these basic writing skills and more on developing and communicating their ideas”
  2. The guide says first writing lessons should begin by showing the child how to hold a pencil comfortably.

    In the source’s own words“Early writing instruction should begin with demonstrations of how to hold a pencil comfortably between the thumb and forefinger, resting on the middle finger”
  3. The guide says to show children the most efficient and readable way to form each letter, in print or in cursive.

    In the source’s own words“Teachers also should show young writers the most efficient and legible ways to form each letter, regardless of whether print or cursive script is used”
  4. The guide suggests guided practice with letters marked by numbered arrows that show the order and direction of each stroke.

    In the source’s own words“Guided practice can be helpful, using letters with numbered arrows depicting the order and direction of each stroke.”
  5. The guide says children should also practice writing letters from memory, with the model covered.

    In the source’s own words“Students also should practice writing letters from memory.”
  6. The guide says a child might write a given letter only five to eight times before moving to something else.

    In the source’s own words“Students might practice a specific letter only five to eight times before moving to another activity.”
  7. The guide says writing single letters is not enough; children should also use their handwriting in sentences and real writing.

    In the source’s own words“However, writing letters in isolation is insufficient; students also should apply their handwriting skills in sentences and in authentic writing activities.”
  8. The guide says which handwriting program is used matters less than teaching smooth, easy letter formation.

    In the source’s own words“The specific curriculum is less important than teaching fluent, effortless letter formation.”

What this means at home

  • Show the pencil hold first, then the way each letter is formed.
  • Keep practice short: a letter a handful of times, then move on.
  • Have your child write letters from memory and use them in real words and sentences.
  • The free handwriting check shows what to work on first.

What the research does not tell us

  • The results the guide reports for this recommendation are writing results (spelling, handwriting, sentences, amount and quality of writing); the passage does not report effects on reading.
  • The panel says it cannot confirm that teaching these skills to a whole class, without matching to each child's needs, would work as well.
  • Most of the studies were done with children at risk for writing difficulties, taught in pairs or small groups.
  • The guide notes that in some studies a gain on one measure came with no effect or a negative effect on another.

Sources

We read each of these ourselves on October 9, 2026. Follow the links to read them too.

  1. Teaching Elementary School Students to Be Effective Writers. Graham, S., Bollinger, A., Booth Olson, C., D'Aoust, C., MacArthur, C., McCutchen, D., & Olinghouse, N.; Institute of Education Sciences, What Works Clearinghouse (NCEE 2012-4058; first published 2012, revised October 2018). 2018.A U.S. government practice guide in which an expert panel made four recommendations for teaching writing in elementary school and rated the evidence behind each.ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc/PracticeGuide/17

How we write these pages

  1. We read the source itself, not a news story about it.
  2. Every finding on a page names its source and where in the source it is found, so you can check it.
  3. We say how strong the evidence is, in the words of the people who reviewed it.
  4. We say what the research does not tell us. Most studies are done in schools, and no study can say what one child needs.
  5. If we get something wrong, tell us at hello@sounditoutreading.com and we will correct the page.

More from The Reading Lab

See all the research pages

More than worksheets

Does this sound like your child?

“Letters are messy, start in the wrong place or face the wrong way”

Start at the Top is a full 10-day plan, with a short video that shows you every step. The goal: on day 10 your child starts every small letter in the right place, sits it on the line, and writes new words that you can read. It is the goal, not a promise.

  • 21 printable pages, one short day at a time
  • 11 short videos that show you each day before you do it
  • 3 sound tracks your child works with alone, while you step away
  • A check on day 1 and day 10, and a report
  • About five minutes a day from you
  • $19, one payment. 30-day money back.

See the 10-day plan →Or do the free 3-minute check first